• Election endorsements and recommendations from CST

Elections

The Coalition of Sensible Taxpayers, Marin’s government watchdog and taxpayer advocate, reviews the key races and tax measures on the ballot and provides our endorsements and recommendations here.

CST Recommendations: November 2024 Marin, Bay Area, and State Tax Measures

Marin Measures


Fairfax road bond – $30/$100K assessed value – Big new tax on same ballot as TUHSD bonds. Ross Valley School District parcel tax coming soon too.

→Vote NO

Novato FOREVER sales tax – increase of 0.75%

→Vote NO

Kentfield School District Bond – $30/$100k assessed value. This will be KSD’s THIRD bond outstanding, funding a laundry list of deferred & future maintenance.

→Vote NO

Sausalito-Marin City School District parcel tax – Needed & fair: $0.25/sq ft, 8 years

→Vote YES

Mill Valley sales tax – 10 year increase of 1.00% for infrastructure

→Vote YES

Tam Union HS District facilities bond – $249MM retry at $18/$100K assessed value

→Neutral. Lower tax than 1st try. Reversing academic slide would be better use of $.

San Rafael Library & community facilities parcel tax – 30 years. $0.145/sq ft of improved property. Needs only 50%+1 to pass. Worthy project but evaded need for 2/3 approval by paying initiative signature gatherers.

→Neutral.

Bay Area Measures


RM4 Bay Area “Unaffordable” Housing bond – 53 years! – Levy averages $19/$100K assessed value annually but peaks at $34/$100K

→DEFEATED with our help!   Measure withdrawn amid voter backlash & lawsuits

State Ballot Propositions


All Require Simple Majority to Pass

Proposition 5: Unleashes a tax tsunami. Lowers hurdle to pass most local bonds to 55% from 2/3.

Vote NO: Making it easier to pass new taxes fuels a tax money grab. This worsens CA’s affordability crisis. Prop 5 removes taxpayer protections; expect other blows to follow.

PROP 5’S PASSAGE WOULD UNLEASH A DRAMATIC SURGE IN NEW TAXES

Proposition 2: Borrow $10 billion to build schools. After cutting school funding, legislature proposes borrowing to pay for construction and modernization.

Vote NO: Adds $1/2 billion yearly to expenses of CA general fund (currently in deficit). Requires local matching funds, increasing the tax burden and favoring wealthy districts.

Proposition 4: Borrow $10 billion for climate programs. A jumble of projects many of which don’t build or repair long-lived assets.

Vote NO: Issues $10 billion in debt to offset $9.4 billion in current year cuts to CA’s Climate Crisis program owing to state budget deficits. Costs $400MM/year for 40 years.

Proposition 33: Allow local governments to impose rent controls. Reverses state law preventing cities & counties from controlling rents on properties occupied post 2/1/95.

Vote NO: Rent control reduces property values, available rentals & housing construction. Lower property tax revenues (per LAO) will prompt other tax hikes.

Future Measures Being Developed:


Bay Area Housing Bond 2nd try – 2026 – specifics TBD

Bay Area Regional Transportation tax – 2026 – specifics TBD

Marin Health Hospital bond – $24/$100K?

Ross Valley School District parcel tax increase – per square foot

SMART sales tax renewal – using citizen initiative route (50%+1)

Marin Wildfire Prevention Authority parcel tax renewal – per square foot