CST Advocacy Helps Secure Marin IJ “NO” on San Rafael Transfer Tax (Measure W)

marin ij no measure w featured

CST Vice President Kingston Cole appeared before the Marin Independent Journal’s editorial board to make the case against Measure W, San Rafael’s proposed real estate transfer tax. The board agreed, issuing a formal “No” endorsement. Below are Cole’s opening remarks, followed by additional points he raised during the session.

Opening remarks from Mr. Cole:

Beginning on a positive note: the Coalition of Sensible Taxpayers and the Marin Association of Realtors have supported numerous San Rafael tax measures over the years — measures that have genuinely benefited residents. We’re proud of the modernized fire stations, the new public safety building, and the soon-to-open community center and library.

Proponents say Measure W is needed to fund roads, emergency services, homelessness support, and other public benefits – services residents already expect from any city, as a matter of course. The real issue isn’t that San Rafael lacks revenue; it’s that San Rafael isn’t operating efficiently. Taxpayer contributions to pension obligations have surged over the past several decades, roads continue to deteriorate, and homelessness remains a persistent, unresolved  problem.

Proponents also call this a “modest” tax. It isn’t – it’s regressive. For someone selling a $4 million home, a $40,000 payment to the city may not register. But for someone selling a million-dollar home – modest by Marin standards – a $10,000 payment is substantial. That’s especially true for seniors whose homes are their only major asset. They may have lived here 40 years, yet the tax is charged on the full sale price – not on how much the home has actually appreciated since they bought it.

Measure W is also a forever tax that, despite our opponents’ claims, can be spent on whatever the city chooses. We believe San Rafael should get its fiscal house in order — not saddle taxpayers with yet another “fix-it tax” that’s really just a general tax in disguise.

Additional remarks from Mr. Cole during the session:

  • Another Merrydale: Mayor Kate and the city failed to meaningfully engage Northgate residents before placing a massive homeless encampment in their community. We noted to the IJ board that the city similarly failed to engage the real estate community before placing this tax on the ballot at the last minute.
  • An out-of-control budget: Asked what budget items CST would target instead, Cole cited five years of failed metrics the city hasn’t addressed, including:
    • Homelessness: no measurable improvement in the count
    • Pavement (Road) Condition Index: dropped five points
    • Public safety compensation: Extravagant salaries for firefighters and EMT’s (they want to add six more with Measure W.), and police officers is crowding out funding for real needs and priorities:
      • The annual total compensation package for a firefighter is $320,000 to $380,000, with EMT’s making over $400,000
      • The Annual total compensation package for a police officer is $220,000 to $250,000.
      • Other city employees demand parity – and receive it 
Scroll to Top